NEXT — 11/17/26

Who Makes the Market? Inside Susquehanna’s Bet on Prediction Markets

By 
@WagerWireEditorial
WagerWire Editorial
At NEXTPredict NYC, Susquehanna's Ric Best joined The Wall Street Journal's Caitlin Ostroff to discuss the evolution of market making, the value of taking risk, and why prediction markets are only scratching the surface of their potential.

Prediction markets are growing at an extraordinary pace, but behind every contract, probability, and price is an essential question: who is actually making the market?

At NEXTPredict NYC, Ric Best, Head of Prediction Markets at Susquehanna International Group (SIG), sat down with The Wall Street Journal's Caitlin Ostroff to explore the institutional infrastructure powering the industry's expansion.

Ostroff, whose reporting has provided valuable insight into the rapidly evolving prediction market landscape, guided a thoughtful conversation that went well beyond the headline growth of the category. From the mechanics of professional market making to the emergence of entirely new financial products, the discussion offered a compelling look at where the wider industry has been and where it could go next.

For Best, that evolution is something he's been experiencing firsthand for years.

Recognizing the Opportunity Before the Crowd

Susquehanna's interest in prediction markets predates the category’s recent surge into the mainstream.

Best explained that Kalshi was among the first platforms to capture the firm's attention. Its approach to federal regulation stood out as a potential game changer, creating a pathway for event contracts to reach a national audience through a regulated exchange.

SIG began developing its prediction-markets operation before 2023, eventually integrating expertise from SIGSports, its Dublin-based trading business, which had already been pricing probability-driven markets beyond traditional sports, including U.S. elections.

Today, the operation has grown to approximately 80 to 90 people, reflecting the scale of Susquehanna's commitment to the asset class.

The underlying philosophy is straightforward. Whether trading stocks, options, or sports contracts, the firm is ultimately assessing probabilities and determining what those outcomes are worth.

It's a philosophy Best understood long before prediction markets became a Wall Street talking point.

As an early buy-side market participant on WagerWire, Best recognized the value of an open, peer-to-peer marketplace for sports positions. Rather than being restricted to traditional sportsbook pricing, he could identify opportunities and trade directly with other participants. Notably, Best was involved in the largest sale in WagerWire history, a milestone that demonstrated his early understanding of price discovery, liquidity, and the opportunities created by open marketplaces.

That experience offers a fitting parallel to his work today. As WagerWire has taken its core competency of regulated marketplace technology and applied it to prediction markets, Best has likewise taken his risk and pricing expertise and applied it at an institutional level, helping Susquehanna build a sophisticated prediction market operation.

According to Best, sports currently represent roughly 70% to 80% of prediction market volume. That momentum is partly a result of familiarity: consumers already understand sports, making those contracts a natural entry point into event-based trading.

But for Susquehanna, sports only represent the beginning.

The Market Maker's Real Advantage

One of the most insightful portions of Ostroff's conversation with Best centered on a common misconception about market makers: that their primary objective is to balance their books and eliminate risk.

Best offered a very different perspective.

At Susquehanna, the emphasis isn't on avoiding exposure but rather to understand probabilities, determine fair prices, and be willing to take positions when the firm's analysis supports them.

While some market participants effectively serve as intermediaries, transferring exposure to another counterparty, Susquehanna is comfortable holding risk. And that means accepting losses.

Best emphasized that the firm is comfortable losing money to variance. A position can be priced correctly and still lose, because even the most sophisticated probability models cannot eliminate uncertainty.

The objective isn't to predict every outcome correctly. It's to consistently price risk accurately over time.

That discipline is supported by extensive research capabilities, with specialists evaluating events, monitoring developments, and translating information into actionable probabilities.

Ostroff's questions helped bring an important distinction into focus: providing liquidity isn't simply about matching buyers and sellers. Effective market making requires capital, conviction, and a willingness to absorb uncertainty.

It's an approach that has helped establish Susquehanna as a major participant in prediction markets, a role that’s only going to gain importance as the category attracts new traders and more complex contracts.

From Sports to AI: A Market for New Risks

While sports remain the industry's primary source of volume, Best sees considerable opportunity beyond traditional event contracts.

During the discussion, he highlighted markets tied to commodities such as tungsten and lean beef, alongside growing interest in contracts related to artificial intelligence. The latter could become particularly significant.

Best suggested that hundreds of billions of dollars in potential exposure may eventually seek ways to hedge AI-related risks. As artificial intelligence transforms industries, companies could face disruptions that conventional financial instruments struggle to accommodate. Traditional insurance doesn't always provide a sufficient solution.

Best pointed to the example of businesses dependent on Major League Baseball. A prolonged labor stoppage could severely affect revenue for nearby bars, vendors, and other businesses, yet insurance against those losses may be difficult to obtain because the financial impact isn't easily measured.

Prediction markets offer a potential alternative.

A clearly defined event contract could allow businesses to hedge against specific outcomes, transferring some of that exposure to participants willing to take the opposite side. This flexibility is what makes the asset class so compelling. With the right contract structure, research, and associated liquidity, previously difficult-to-price risks could become exchange-listed products.

For firms like Susquehanna, the opportunity extends far beyond making markets on which team wins a championship; it's to help create entirely new ways for businesses and individuals to manage uncertainty.

Building the Next Generation of Markets

Throughout the conversation, Ostroff and Best highlighted an important reality: prediction markets are about much more than the probabilities displayed on a screen.

Behind those numbers are sophisticated pricing models, research teams, market makers, and participants willing to back their positions with real capital.

The discussion also illustrated how the industry's growth is bringing together expertise from otherwise distinct worlds: sports betting, financial exchanges, commodities, and institutional trading.

Best's own career is a fitting example. From recognizing opportunities on WagerWire's early secondary marketplace, including his involvement in a peer-to-peer transaction with no prior precedent at the time, to overseeing Susquehanna's expanding prediction markets operation, he has consistently understood the value of liquidity, price discovery, and open trading.

Ostroff's engaging moderation helped connect that experience to the broader questions facing the industry; specifically how these markets mature, where institutional capital finds opportunity, and what happens as event contracts expand into unfamiliar territory.

For an industry often dominated by conversations about trading volume and regulatory uncertainty, their discussion provided a valuable look at the people and principles making it all possible.

Sports may have introduced prediction markets to the mainstream, but their next chapter could be considerably larger. As Best made clear, the firms that understand how to price uncertainty and embrace risk will play a central role in writing it.